About Caroline M. Elliot

Legal Representation For Hawai’i

About Caroline M. Elliot – Dedicated Criminal Defense Attorney

When you face the criminal justice system, you need someone who will fight for you—someone who understands the challenges and has the experience to navigate complex legal issues. 

With over a decade of experience in both North Carolina and Hawai`i, Caroline has dedicated her career to defending the rights of individuals facing some of the most serious charges. 

Her commitment to justice and her passion for helping those vulnerable in the system make her a formidable force in the courtroom.

Contact Caroline today at (808) 570-6003 to discuss your case and learn how she can fight for your rights.

Lifetime Commitment As An Advocate 

Caroline

Caroline’s career as a criminal defense attorney is rooted in a lifetime commitment to advocating for those who struggle against the system. 

Starting as a teenager, she participated in a teen court program to divert young offenders away from traditional criminal justice, offering them an alternative path. She also participated in both Moot Court and Mock Trial in high school.

This drive continued through her college years at Clemson University where she played in the Marching Band and also met her husband. Later, as a law student at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, she led the Innocence Project and Death Penalty Project, advocating for justice in some of the most serious and sensitive cases.

Caroline interned at the Center for Death Penalty Litigation and later at the Wake County Public Defender’s Office.

She began working as an assistant public defender at the Wake County Public Defender’s Office after graduation in 2008. At the Public Defender’s Office, she worked 12 years, starting out in the Misdemeanor unit and then progressing to the Felony unit. By the end of her time there, she was handling the most serious cases. 

Caroline and her husband then moved to Hawai’i where Caroline took the Hawai’i bar exam in July 2021. She was licensed as an attorney in Hawaii in December 2021.

Today, as a highly respected criminal defense attorney in Hawai`i, Caroline handles a range of complex cases, from high-level felonies and first-degree murder trials to federal cases involving drugs, white collar crimes, and gun offenses

Her approach is both strategic and compassionate—always working closely with her clients to ensure that their voices are heard and their rights are protected.

Help Navigating the Complex Judicial System

The criminal justice system can be intimidating, especially when you’re facing serious charges. The consequences can be severe, and without a strong defense, you may risk losing your freedom, your rights, and your future.

The system can feel stacked against you. The legal complexities, the emotional toll, and the fear of long-term consequences make it difficult to focus on your defense. You need someone who not only understands the law but also genuinely cares about your outcome and will fight tirelessly to protect your rights.

At the Law Office of Caroline M. Elliot, you get more than just a legal advocate—you get a passionate defender who knows how to navigate both state and federal courts. 

Caroline’s extensive experience with serious felony cases and her deep understanding of the complexities of the criminal justice system ensures that you’ll have the most vigorous possible defense. 

Whether it’s fighting for an acquittal, reducing charges, or negotiating favorable plea deals, Caroline is there to secure the best possible outcome for your case.

Contact Caroline at (808) 570-6003 for a FREE consultation, and let her guide you through your defense with compassion, experience, and a fierce dedication to your rights.

Working with The Law Office of Caroline M. Elliot

Choosing the right criminal defense attorney can make all the difference when facing serious charges or navigating post-conviction challenges.

At the Law Office of Caroline M. Elliot, we offer more than just legal experience—we provide personalized, compassionate, and aggressive representation that sets us apart in Hawai’i’s criminal defense landscape.

Here’s how working with us can benefit you:

Personalized Legal Strategy for Every Case

Caroline takes the time to understand the specific details of your case, whether you’re dealing with DUI charges, drug offenses, or a federal gun charge.

We don’t use a one-size-fits-all approach. Instead, we craft tailored legal strategies that best serve your situation and goals, providing you with a customized defense plan designed to achieve your best possible outcome.

Comprehensive Services Beyond Defense

Our law firm doesn’t just stop at defending clients in court. We also provide post-conviction relief services, including expungement and parole assistance for those with criminal records.

Whether you need to clear your record or make a fresh start, we’re here to guide you through the legal processes that can help you rebuild your life after a conviction.

Experienced in Both State and Federal Cases

Navigating complex state and federal laws can be overwhelming. Caroline has extensive experience handling cases at both levels, including federal drug charges, white-collar crimes, and gun offenses.

This dual experience ensures you have strong representation, whether your case falls under Hawai’i law or federal jurisdiction.

Empathy and Support Throughout the Process

We understand that facing criminal charges can be one of the most stressful times in a person’s life. At the Law Office of Caroline M. Elliot, we provide more than just legal advice—we offer empathy, support, and clear communication to help you feel confident about your case.

We ensure you’re informed and supported at every stage of the legal process so you never feel like you’re facing this battle alone.

Aggressive Advocacy for Your Future

Caroline is known for her dedication to fighting for her clients’ rights. Whether in court defending against DUI charges, helping clients challenge convictions, or negotiating favorable plea deals, we fight to protect your freedom and future.

Our firm seeks the best possible results, whether a reduced sentence, dismissal, or plea bargain. We also facilitate complex post-conviction remedies like governor-level pardons.

The Law Office of Caroline M. Elliot offers more experience in Hawai’i’s legal landscape—our combination of legal experience, personalized attention, and unwavering commitment to your success is unmatched.

Contact us today for a FREE consultation. Let’s work together to build a robust defense strategy that protects your rights and future.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does your experience with high-profile cases and serious charges in Hawai`i shape your approach to defending clients today?

Caroline’s experience with high-profile cases and serious charges in Hawai`i has significantly shaped her approach to criminal defense.

Throughout her career, she has handled a wide range of complex cases, including murder trials, federal crimes, and severe felony charges. This experience has helped her develop a strategic and thorough approach to defending clients, ensuring the examination of every detail of the case to the client’s advantage.

Her work on serious charges has taught her the importance of thorough investigation and case preparation. For every case, Caroline meticulously reviews evidence, interviews witnesses, and collaborates with experts to challenge the prosecution’s narrative. This detailed approach allows her to anticipate potential challenges in court and build a strong defense strategy that is tailored to the specifics of each client’s case.

Moreover, Caroline’s experience with high-stakes cases has made her a formidable advocate in the courtroom. Her ability to navigate complex legal arguments and present compelling cases to judges and juries makes her highly effective in defending her clients.

Whether the case involves federal drug charges, white-collar crimes, or gun-related offenses, Caroline is skilled at presenting a defense that challenges the evidence and emphasizes her clients’ rights.

In addition to her courtroom prowess, Caroline’s deep understanding of the criminal justice system enables her to negotiate favorable plea deals when appropriate, minimizing the potential penalties her clients face. Her relationships with prosecutors and her respected reputation as a lawyer of integrity often give her an edge in negotiations, helping clients avoid the most severe consequences.

In summary, Caroline’s extensive experience with serious charges in Hawai`i ensures that she provides her clients with a comprehensive and aggressive defense. She employs her knowledge of the law, investigative skills, and courtroom experience to fight for the best possible outcome in every case.

Want to learn more about how our experience with serious cases can shape your defense? Call us today at (808) 570-6003 for a FREE consultation.

What makes you uniquely qualified to handle both state and federal criminal cases, especially serious charges like drug offenses, white-collar crimes, or gun-related crimes?

Caroline’s unique qualifications stem from her extensive experience navigating both state and federal criminal courts in Hawai`i.

Handling serious charges such as federal drug offenses, white-collar crimes, and gun-related crimes requires a deep understanding of the nuanced differences between state and federal law. Caroline brings a wealth of experience to both arenas.

Comprehensive Knowledge of State and Federal Law

Federal cases often involve more severe penalties, complex regulations, and a higher level of scrutiny.

Caroline is uniquely equipped to handle these cases because of her years of experience working in federal court, where she has defended clients against serious charges that carry significant consequences.

Her experience includes navigating the intricacies of federal sentencing guidelines, mandatory minimums, and evidentiary standards, which can differ significantly from state law.

Her understanding of the procedural and substantive differences between federal and state systems allows her to effectively advocate for her clients, whether they are facing state-level criminal charges or more complex federal indictments.

Strategic Approach to Serious Offenses

Caroline’s background in handling drug offenses, white-collar crimes, and gun-related charges gives her a strategic edge in defending clients. These types of cases often involve intricate legal issues such as search and seizure rights, forensic evidence, and financial records analysis.

Caroline has the ability to dissect complex legal problems and develop robust defense strategies that challenge the prosecution’s case on multiple fronts.

For drug charges, for example, she examines the legality of the arrest, the handling of evidence, and potential constitutional violations to protect her clients’ rights. In white-collar cases, she can dissect financial records and present alternative narratives to weaken the prosecution’s claims.

Experience with Serious and High-Profile Cases

Caroline has a track record of defending clients against serious charges, including murder trials and high-level felonies.

This experience has honed her skills in courtroom advocacy and negotiation, both of which are critical when defending against severe criminal charges. Her ability to present persuasive arguments in front of both state and federal judges, coupled with her experience in negotiating favorable plea deals, ensures that her clients receive the most aggressive defense possible.

Her reputation as a formidable advocate also means that prosecutors take her defense strategies seriously, which can lead to more favorable outcomes for her clients.

Personalized Defense for Complex Cases

What sets Caroline apart is her personalized approach to each case. Federal and state charges require different defense strategies, and Caroline customizes her approach based on the specifics of each client’s situation.

She ensures that every aspect of a case, from pre-trial motions to courtroom presentations, is tailored to maximize the chances of success.

For example, in federal drug cases, she may focus on attacking the credibility of government witnesses, while in state-level gun charges, she might emphasize constitutional violations or missteps in law enforcement procedures.

Deep Understanding of the Local Legal Landscape

Caroline’s experience in Hawai`i gives her a unique advantage when it comes to understanding the local legal environment.

She is familiar with local prosecutors, judges, and court procedures, which allows her to anticipate the opposition’s strategies and adapt her defense accordingly. This local experience, combined with her federal experience, means that her clients receive a well-rounded, informed defense that considers both local and national legal perspectives.

Caroline’s qualifications are rooted in her extensive experience with both state and federal criminal cases, her strategic approach to serious charges, and her deep understanding of the legal nuances in Hawai`i. This makes her uniquely equipped to defend clients facing some of the most serious legal challenges.

Facing state or federal charges? Contact us now at (808) 570-6003 for a FREE consultation to discuss your case and see how our dual experience can benefit you.

Can you explain how your involvement in the Innocence Project and Death Penalty Project impacts your approach to complex criminal cases and post-conviction appeals?

Caroline’s involvement in the Innocence Project and the Death Penalty Project has profoundly shaped her approach to complex criminal cases and post-conviction appeals.

Her work in these initiatives has given her a unique perspective on the justice system’s failings and, for those facing wrongful convictions or severe penalties like the death penalty, the crucial role of:

  • Thorough investigation
  • Meticulous attention to detail
  • Unwavering advocacy

Commitment to Justice and Protecting Constitutional Rights

Working with the Innocence Project, Caroline has directly seen how the justice system can fail individuals—especially when evidence is mishandled, wrongful accusations are made, or essential constitutional rights are violated.

This experience informs her approach to every criminal defense case, ensuring no stone is left unturned when defending her clients.

She is particularly attuned to potential violations of her client’s rights, such as improper police procedures, prosecutorial misconduct, or the use of faulty forensic evidence, all of which can lead to wrongful convictions.

In complex criminal cases, Caroline approaches each case with an investigative mindset. She examines all aspects of the case for errors or injustices, whether it involves improper interrogations, misidentification, or failure to disclose exculpatory evidence.

A Rigorous Approach to Evidence and Case Review

Caroline’s involvement in the Death Penalty Project, where the stakes are at their highest, has given her a deep understanding of the importance of rigorous evidence review.

In cases involving serious charges like murder, where life and death hang in the balance, she has honed the ability to dissect evidence with meticulous care.

This skill translates into her work on complex criminal cases and post-conviction appeals, where it’s crucial to identify any errors that could overturn a conviction or lead to a reduced sentence, such as:

  • Trial records
  • Witness testimonies
  • Forensic evidence

Her experience with these projects gives her the ability to spot weak points in the prosecution’s case and leverage them to her clients’ advantage. In post-conviction appeals, she often focuses on uncovering new evidence or legal arguments that weren’t fully explored during the initial trial.

Holistic Understanding of the Appeals Process

Her work with the Death Penalty Project has exposed her to the multi-layered appeals process, particularly in cases where clients face the most severe penalties.

As a result, she understands the complexities of post-conviction appeals, from initial motions to higher court reviews. Caroline applies this knowledge in her work with clients seeking relief after conviction, whether it’s:

  • Filing for an appeal based on new evidence
  • Arguing that their trial was constitutionally flawed
  • Fighting for post-conviction remedies like expungement

Clients who face serious charges benefit from her knowledge of both trial strategy and the intricacies of post-conviction appeals. She understands the emotional and procedural challenges involved in these cases and provides solid legal advocacy every step of the way.

Passion for Exonerating the Innocent

Caroline’s passion for exonerating the wrongfully convicted drives her relentless pursuit of justice for her clients.

In her work with the Innocence Project, she witnessed firsthand the devastating impact of wrongful convictions and how individuals can be incarcerated for years—sometimes decades—for crimes they didn’t commit.

This passion fuels her commitment to fighting for those who may have been wrongfully accused or convicted, especially in complex criminal cases involving significant penalties.

She brings this same dedication to every case she takes on, whether it’s a pre-trial defense or a post-conviction appeal, and focuses on ensuring the best outcome for her clients.

Experience with High-Stakes Cases

Having worked on death penalty cases, Caroline is no stranger to high-pressure situations and high-stakes outcomes. This experience equips her to handle the emotional and legal challenges of defending clients in serious criminal cases, including those facing federal charges or long-term imprisonment.

Her calm under pressure, combined with her strategic approach to defense, ensures that her clients receive the most vigorous possible representation, even when the odds seem stacked against them.

Fighting For Your Rights In Complex Situations

Caroline’s work with the Innocence Project and the Death Penalty Project has made her a stronger, more empathetic, and more rigorous advocate for clients facing complex criminal charges and post-conviction appeals.

Her commitment to justice, deep knowledge of the appeals process, and experience in handling the most serious of cases make her uniquely qualified to fight for her clients’ rights and help those wrongfully convicted or facing severe penalties.

Have questions about post-conviction appeals or complex criminal cases? Reach out at (808) 570-6003 for a FREE consultation to explore your legal options.

What strategies do you use to help clients pursue post-conviction relief, such as expungement, and how do you assist them in rebuilding their lives after a criminal record?

Caroline uses a combination of legal experience, personalized client care, and strategic planning to help individuals seeking post-conviction relief such as expungement or pardons.

Her focus is not just on clearing the legal record but also on empowering clients to rebuild their lives after a criminal conviction.

Here’s an in-depth look at how she approaches these processes and the strategies she employs to help her clients succeed.

Thorough Evaluation of Eligibility for Expungement

One of the first steps Caroline takes in helping clients pursue expungement is conducting a thorough evaluation of their eligibility.

In Hawaii, the rules surrounding expungement can be complex, with certain types of convictions qualifying for expungement while others may not. Caroline carefully reviews each client’s criminal record to determine whether they are eligible under the state’s expungement laws.

She also examines the type of offense, whether it has been sufficient time since the conviction, and whether the client has fulfilled all court-ordered requirements like probation or restitution.

For clients who are eligible, Caroline meticulously prepares and submits the necessary documents and petitions to the court, ensuring all legal procedures are followed. If the case involves federal crimes, she advises on how those charges might affect state-level expungement or other post-conviction relief options.

Personalized Approach to Post-Conviction Relief

Caroline takes a personalized approach to each case, knowing that no two clients’ situations are the same.

For clients seeking post-conviction relief, she spends time understanding their individual circumstances and goals. She tailors her approach to fit the specific needs of the client.

For example, she helps clients gather evidence of rehabilitation, such as letters of recommendation from employers or proof of community involvement, to strengthen their case for expungement.

By providing clients with a clear roadmap of the process, she ensures they understand each step and what is required to achieve their goals.

Helping Clients Access Employment and Housing Opportunities

One of the most important aspects of rebuilding life after a criminal conviction is gaining access to stable employment and housing.

A criminal record can be a significant barrier to these opportunities, even if the conviction is old or minor. Caroline works with her clients to remove these barriers by clearing their records, helping them understand their rights, and advocating for fair treatment in job and housing applications.

For clients who have successfully expunged their records, she provides guidance on how to navigate background checks and what rights they have when it comes to disclosing their criminal past.

This kind of support helps her clients feel more confident when re-entering the workforce or securing stable housing.

Long-Term Support and Guidance

Even after the legal process is complete, Caroline provides ongoing support to her clients as they rebuild their lives. She understands that clearing a criminal record is just the beginning of a long journey, and she remains available to answer questions and provide guidance as clients navigate their post-conviction lives.

This long-term relationship ensures that her clients have the resources and support they need to fully reintegrate into society and move forward with their lives.

Receive the Best Possible Guidance and Legal Representation

Caroline’s approach to post-conviction relief focuses on empowering her clients to move forward with their lives. Whether it’s through expungement or advocacy for fair employment and housing opportunities, she provides personalized, strategic support to help clients rebuild after a criminal record.

Her commitment to understanding each client’s unique needs ensures that they receive the best possible guidance and representation throughout the process.

Looking to rebuild your life after a conviction? Call us at (808) 570-6003 for a FREE consultation and learn how we can assist with expungement and more.

How do you balance aggressive defense strategies with maintaining integrity and a positive reputation with judges and prosecutors?

Caroline’s ability to balance aggressive defense strategies with maintaining integrity and a positive reputation with judges and prosecutors is a core aspect of her successful legal career.

In criminal defense, achieving the best results for clients often requires a fine balance between fighting hard for their rights while also building credibility and trust within the legal community.

Here’s how she maintains this balance:

Fierce Advocacy for Clients’ Rights

Caroline approaches each case with a deep commitment to defending her clients vigorously, particularly when they are facing serious charges that could result in life-changing consequences.

She develops a robust and thorough defense strategy based on investigating all aspects of the case throughout the legal process:

  • Challenging weak or faulty evidence
  • Ensuring that her clients’ constitutional rights are fully protected

Whether defending against drug charges, federal offenses, or navigating complex appeals, Caroline is relentless in her pursuit of justice for her clients.

However, she understands that being aggressive in the courtroom does not mean being confrontational or unethical. Her strategies focus on using the law effectively, knowing when to push for dismissals, plea deals, or full trials, and ensuring that every aspect of the case is airtight from a legal perspective.

Building Credibility with Judges and Prosecutors

Caroline has earned a reputation for integrity and professionalism in the legal community. This credibility is crucial when advocating for her clients, as it allows her to build productive working relationships with judges and prosecutors.

She understands that a positive rapport with these critical figures can lead to:

  • Better negotiations
  • More favorable plea deals
  • A higher chance of reducing or dismissing charges

Judges and prosecutors know they can trust Caroline to argue fairly and ethically, even when she is fiercely defending her client’s rights.

This reputation is built on years of demonstrating that she follows court procedures, presents well-reasoned legal arguments, and abides by the rules of professional conduct. While she does not hesitate to challenge opposing arguments, she does so with respect for the legal process and those involved.

Strategic Use of Negotiations

One of the hallmarks of Caroline’s defense strategies is knowing when and how to negotiate with prosecutors to achieve the best possible outcomes for her clients.

Negotiating plea deals is an art that requires both assertiveness and diplomacy. By maintaining her reputation as a trustworthy and professional attorney, Caroline can negotiate from a position of strength without alienating prosecutors or pushing too hard in a way that might jeopardize her clients’ chances.

Her approach involves:

  • Thoroughly preparing the case
  • Understanding the prosecution’s weaknesses
  • Using that knowledge to propose favorable plea deals or reduced sentences

Her positive relationships with prosecutors allow for more effective communication, which benefits her clients when plea deals are on the table.

Maintaining Ethical Standards

Caroline’s commitment to ethical standards is central to her legal practice. While she aggressively defends her clients, she never compromises her ethical obligations to the court or her clients.

This means she presents cases honestly, avoids misleading the court, and ensures that her clients fully understand the legal process and their options. By maintaining these ethical standards, she builds trust not only with her clients but also with the judges and prosecutors she works with.

In high-stakes cases, such as murder trials or federal crimes, this integrity becomes even more critical. Caroline knows that maintaining her ethical obligations strengthens her long-term ability to advocate for her clients effectively.

Courts and prosecutors respect lawyers who fight hard but remain ethical and professional, which can influence outcomes in close or contentious cases.

Tailoring Aggressiveness to the Situation

Caroline’s experience allows her to understand when to be aggressive and when a more measured approach is appropriate.

In some cases, taking a hardline stance in court is necessary to protect her client’s rights, especially when facing overzealous prosecution or weak evidence. In other instances, a cooperative approach can yield better results, particularly in plea negotiations or post-conviction relief efforts.

By tailoring her approach to each situation, Caroline ensures that her defense strategies are as effective as possible while maintaining the respect of the court and the opposition. This situational awareness allows her to maximize her clients’ chances of success without alienating those involved in the legal process.

Experienced Courtroom Litigation and Skilled Negotiation

Caroline’s ability to balance aggressive defense strategies with maintaining integrity and professionalism is vital to her success as a criminal defense attorney in Hawai`i.

She fiercely advocates for her clients’ rights yet does so in a way that earns the respect and trust of judges and prosecutors. This balance allows her to provide the most vigorous possible defense for her clients.

By being strategic, ethical, and adaptable, Caroline secures the best outcomes for her clients, whether through courtroom litigation or skilled negotiation.

Ready to work with an attorney who fights for you while maintaining integrity? Contact us at (808) 570-6003 to schedule your FREE consultation.

Contact Us

Get In touch

Let Us know how we can help you

Benefits Of Working With The Law Office Of Caroline M. Elliot

Comprehensive Knowledge of Hawai'i & Federal Criminal Defense Law

Minimization of Penalties: Our Aim Is to Reduce Penalties or Dismiss Charges

Robust and Comprehensive Defense Strategy

We Review Your Arrest and Look For Procedural Errors to Protect Your Rights

Clear Communication and Guidance Every Step